Intrinsically Ordered
Exploring the intersection of queer identity and catholicism - sharing stories of those who've left, remained, and created their own journeys; providing commentary on the catholic church's harmful teachings; helping those who've been hurt.
Intrinsically Ordered
Why The Supreme Court Is Confused About Religious Freedom: St Mary's v Roy Oral Arguments Reaction
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Supreme Court just heard oral arguments in a major religious freedom case involving Catholic schools, LGBTQ families, and Colorado's taxpayer-funded preschool program. Can Catholic schools receive public funding while refusing to admit children because their parents are gay?
I'm joined by @cdamianwrites , a Catholic lawyer and writer, and Simon Kent-Fung, creator of the award-winning "Dear Alana" podcast, to break down the case, the oral arguments, and what this could mean for religious liberty in America.
We discuss the Archdiocese of Denver's lawsuit against Colorado, the Becket Fund's legal strategy, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson's questions about racial discrimination, and why several Supreme Court justices seemed confused about what exactly they were being asked to decide.
We also examine the Catholic Church's own teachings on unjust discrimination, the history of religious freedom cases like 'Employment Division v. Smith' and 'Carson v. Makin,' and whether this latest lawsuit could ultimately backfire on religious institutions.
As someone who has spent years studying Catholicism, LGBTQ issues, and the intersection of religion and law, I think this case raises much bigger questions than simply who gets admitted to a Catholic preschool.
Chris Damien: https://chrisdamien.substack.com
Simon Kent Fong: https://simonkentfeng.com
Subscribe to Intrinsically Ordered for more conversations about Catholicism, religious deconstruction, LGBTQ issues, and the law.
00:00 Welcome and Why Today
00:49 Case Overview Colorado Pre-K
02:12 Funding vs Discrimination Rules
03:31 Supreme Court Standards Explained
06:29 Colorado’s LGBT Religion Legal History
09:20 Neutral Laws vs Religious Animus
13:05 Why the Justices Asked Why Here
20:00 Crash Course Key Precedents
24:47 Culture War Optics and Real Families
30:11 Downstream Effects If Colorado Loses
37:20 Oral Argument Vibes and Justice Dynamics
45:35 Protected Classes and Catholic Teaching Tension
49:10 When Liberty Backfires
50:23 Power Shifts and Smith
51:09 Conscience Versus Religion
53:45 Why This Case Exists
56:10 Catholic Liberty Misused
58:48 Prudence and Admissions
01:02:11 Justices Seek the Harm
01:08:43 Precedent and Carve Outs
01:11:22 Public Private Blur
01:16:29 Predictions and Outcomes
To join our discord community for $1 or to support my work/get early access to content, check out my patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/gayextrad
To be a guest on the episode, visit my YT channel and send me an email.